A Question Posed to an Era That Has Degraded Humans into Calculators
What was the true essence of the "Civilization" that humanity so painstakingly built? It was a magnificent journey to erect defensive walls of morality, law, and institutions, ensuring that humans would not be helplessly driven by blind animalistic instincts, immediate tooth-and-nail survival, or mere incentives.
Left in a state of nature, humans would have acted thoroughly according to costs and benefits. If food were scarce, plundering the weak yields low costs and high benefits, making it a perfectly "rational choice."
Civilization, however, is a collective pact and a framework designed precisely to defy that impulse. It sought to rescue humanity from the slavery of incentives by structuring a reality where we help the vulnerable even at an immediate personal loss (welfare), and where we do not covet another’s property even when gain rolls right before our eyes (law). The greatness of civilization depended entirely on how sublimely humans could transcend economic calculation.
Yet today, we live in a bizarre era where the purpose of civilization has been completely inverted. Economics, having seized dominance by slapping a price tag on every phenomenon in the world, has colonized even the noble defensive walls of civilization, dismissing them as "just another market that humans created after calculating the costs."
An Inverted Logic That Degraded an Instrument of Regulation into a Device of Calculation
The contemporary approach to the unprecedented ultra-low fertility crisis is a prime example of this degradation.
A healthy, functioning civilized society should naturally confront this tragedy with philosophical and structural inquiries: "Why have the youth lost the capacity to dream of a future and bear children? Let us fix this painful social structure and restore human dignity."
Yet, the approach of a dominant economics is astonishingly shallow and mechanical. It taps away on a pocket calculator, declaring, "Since not having children is a rational calculation for young people, let’s throw in a bit more financial subsidy (incentive) to entice them into purchasing the commodity known as childbirth."
An instrument of civilization (policy) that was meant to redeem humanity from the shackles of incentives has instead been corrupted into a tool to turn humans into even more meticulous calculators.
The Sorrowful Reason Why Economics Fits Reality So Perfectly
Many people nod along in agreement when love, crime, and the breakdown of the family are explained through the lens of economics. This happens not because economic theory is so magnificent that it borders on absolute truth. Tragically, it is because modern civilization is failing catastrophically to maintain the structures meant to protect human beings.
As run-away capitalism accelerates, the defensive walls of morality, solidarity, trust, and community—which civilization once steadfastly guarded—have collapsed one after another under the raw power of money. With these sturdy defense lines erased, humans have been driven back into a state of nature, forced into a brutal war of all against all where they must calculate nothing but "the cost of survival" and "personal benefit."
The landscape where the cold equations of economics align perfectly with reality is not a triumph of the discipline. It is merely the most definitive, sorrowful evidence that our civilization has regressed humans into snobs driven exclusively by costs and benefits.
Conclusion: Why the Throne of the Empire Must Be Overthrown
Civilization is a grand architecture built specifically to avoid being subjugated by economic rationality. Where the defensive lines of civilization—which vowed "never to make humans slaves to money"—crumbled, economics seized dominance and claimed the imperial throne.
Economists flaunt their hubris, boasting that they explain human choice best, but the human being they describe is stripped of the clothes of civilization—reduced to a state of naked savagery.
Now, instead of applauding the audacious territories economics has conquered, we must contemplate how to rebuild the collapsed defense lines of our civilization. Re-engineering a structure where humans can be safe without having to hide behind calculators; stripping economics of its cold, dominating power; and restoring a society with a human face—this is the real, pressing task facing a civilization that has ceased to evolve and begun to regress.
Leave a Reply