Infant Memories Are Very Short
We remember very little from immediately after we are born.
Yet developmental theory often says this:
“Learning attitudes and values formed in infancy remain for life.”
At first glance, this sounds contradictory.
Do not attitudes and values continue to change throughout life?
Do not our thoughts shift, our standards of judgment change, and our life goals transform?
So what does this statement actually mean?
Attitudes and Values Do Change
First, something must be made clear.
People’s attitudes and values do in fact change.
Political positions, moral judgments, and relational priorities are continuously revised through experience and learning.
So if we take the phrase “values formed in infancy last a lifetime” literally, it would be incorrect.
The problem arises when we fail to distinguish precisely what is said to “remain.”
Infancy Does Not Form “Content”
Infancy is not the period in which the content of values is learned.
Infants cannot conceptually understand “this is right” or “this is important.”
Instead, what is formed in this period are bodily answers to questions like:
Is this situation safe or threatening?
Is it okay to try, or better to stop?
If I ask for help, will someone respond?
If I fail, will the relationship remain?
In other words, infancy is not the time for learning what to believe,
but for learning how to believe.
What Remains Is Not Values, but “Grammar”
Once this distinction is understood, the statement becomes clear.
What remains from infancy is not ideology or belief,
but the basic grammar through which the world is interpreted.
By analogy:
what is installed in infancy is an operating system (OS),
and the values and beliefs learned in adulthood are more like apps installed on top of it.
Apps can be changed easily.
But while the OS can be updated, its fundamental structure is not easily altered.
This is why people often say,
“My thoughts have changed, but my body remains the same.”
The Precise Meaning of “Lasts a Lifetime”
This statement should be understood like this:
Infant memories disappear.
But the neural response rules formed through those memories remain for a long time.
These rules operate before we are even consciously aware of them:
Do I tense up first when learning something new?
Does asking for help feel safe?
When I fail, do I shrink back—or try again?
In relationships, do I always become the one who adjusts first?
These are closer to reflexes than to choices.
That is why similar reactions are repeatedly triggered in similar situations,
no matter how much our conscious thinking changes.
So Does It Really Never Change?
Not exactly.
It simply changes in a different way.
This basic grammar does not shift easily through explanation or persuasion alone—
because “understanding” and “the body changing” are not the same thing.
Change usually occurs very slowly through:
repeated relational experiences,
environments where failure is safe,
and emotional–somatic re-learning.
This is why recovery feels slow,
and why people become frustrated with themselves.
What This Statement Ultimately Means
What “lasts a lifetime” is not a fixed set of values.
What remains is the posture through which we receive values,
the bodily attitude with which we stand before learning,
and the fundamental way we trust the world.
Understanding this is not meant to say “it is already too late,”
but to explain fairly why change is slow
and why effort alone is often insufficient.
The memories have disappeared,
but the grammar formed then is still operating within us.
And it, too, is something that can be relearned—
through time and experience.
If you enjoyed this piece:
Explore the “A Greenhouse for Tender Things” collection
Discover more from the Abstract collection
Leave a Reply